Skip to main content
#
Rutledge Law
site map
contact
email usour twitter linkdin
RutLaw Blog
Sunday, August 09 2020

I attended the swearing in of a new judge in Montgomery County, Texas last week.  It was the first time I had been inside a courthouse since March. That six-month drought is the longest I can recall ... The deputies were taking temperatures, and they asked all entering to verify their good health.  Inside a fairly full courtroom, people wore masks.  People cooperated, were of good cheer, and it worked. 

And we need for it to work ... for us to get back in courtrooms and in front of juries.  

Like pretty much all trial lawyers, I have attended my fair share of remote hearings and depositions.  These have worked (mostly) though there have been some technological snafus; in fact, this is the norm rather than the exception. The simple act of presenting documents to a witness in a deposition is now an achievement, in and of itself. And in a deposition last week, we had to stop because a storm hit Austin where one lawyer was ... knocked out his internet.  There was also the witness who had a "helper" in the room (off-camera).  Regarding mediations, mediators report these are happening but that it is generally harder to close the deal.  It makes sense. 

Ours is an interpersonal business.  Our rules require presonally contronting parties and evidence and we also have juries who hear and decide cases. Juries look at the witnesses, size them up, and they handle (yes, physically handle) and review the evidence. Think about the dynamics of in-person communications as compared to all other forms.  Eighty (80) percent of communication is non-verbal. And seeing and interacting with a live human accomplishes this translation better. That is, face-to-face is the best way to get to the bottom of things, and that is what lawsuits are about. We can do remote hearings and depositions on some level, but in the end, we have to get back in front of courts and juries. And, oh, our rules of evidence and procedure require that we do.   

So, my trip back to court showed me that courts are ready and can put procedures in place to make this happen.  Let's spread juries out, sit them in the gallery, if need be.  Reconfigure the courtroom. Have people put masks on. Do what we need to do to keep our system of jusice running.  

Historically, lawyers have been statesmen and leaders in our culture. It is time to do that and be a part of getting back to normal. 

See you in court. 

Posted by: RickR AT 05:14 pm   |  Permalink   |  Email

TERMS OF USE: This website is solely for informational purposes.  It is not to be considered legal advice.  Please speak with an attorney at this firm or of your own choice to obtain legal advice in connection with any specific matter. In no event will the firm or its attorneys be responsible for loss/damages resulting from any usage of the materials on this website. 

    Contact Information

    Rutledge Law Office, P.C.
    8701 New Trails Drive, Suite 200
    The Woodlands, TX 77381
    phone: 281.528.1535

    email: rickr@rutledgelaw.net

    © 2024 All Rights Reserved

    We Serve Our Clients

    We have a track record of obtaining successful results throughout Texas -- in state and federal courts, as well as arbitrations. Led by an AV-Rated trial lawyer (Preeminent 2012, 2021, 2022, and 2023) who has been voted one of Houston's Best Lawyers in 2008 and again by his peers in 2017, our trial practice focuses on construction, commercial, tort, and indemnity/insurance. We also provide proactive counsel to small businesses on myriad topics. Rick Rutledge is Board Certified by the Texas Board of Legal Specialization in Personal Injury Trial Law.

    email usour twitter linkdin
    powered by:
       Company Studio