Skip to main content
#
Rutledge Law
site map
contact
email usour twitter linkdin
RutLaw Blog
Friday, August 13 2021

I recently got a summons to jury duty.  It was interesting to be on the other side of the bar, to be questioned by the lawyers about whetther i should serve on the jury.  Turns out, I was the man who knew too much, so ... I was excused. 

A couple of weeks prior I was talking to a juror after a trial (in my usual role).  It was pretty apparent to me that this juror had not followed the Court's instructions in reaching his verdict. He was earnest, and he believed he had some personal know-how that was appropriate to bring to bear in the case (though the instructions said not to do so).   

I have also have my usual dealings with judges and witnesses ... Slometimes both judges make mistakes (I have heard) and sometimes witnesses do, too (maybe they have an off day).  

But the point is ... we all have a role to play in our judical system. And we need those roles to be fulfilled and done well.   

We need the judges to make rulings, both impartiallly and prediciably, so that we can know how to try our cases (or not, that is, to settle them). 

We need lawyers to advocate zealously within the bounds of the law, arguing every reasonable inference while understanding that we are not entitled to our own facts. 

We need juroris to follow the Court's instructions and judge the facts accordingly. 

And we need citizens to show up for jury duty and also, as witnesses, testify truthfully and provide information needed to resolve our disputes. 

These roles, sometimes in tension, are all necessary.  

We all have a role to play to make our judicial system work. 

Our criticisms of our judicial system ultimately falls to each of us to address. 

Posted by: RickR AT 11:37 pm   |  Permalink   |  Email

TERMS OF USE: This website is solely for informational purposes.  It is not to be considered legal advice.  Please speak with an attorney at this firm or of your own choice to obtain legal advice in connection with any specific matter. In no event will the firm or its attorneys be responsible for loss/damages resulting from any usage of the materials on this website. Please also note that unless otherwise noted within this site, attorneys not certified by the Texas Board of Legal Specialization.

    Contact Information

    Rutledge Law Office, P.C.
    8701 New Trails Drive, Suite 200
    The Woodlands, TX 77381
    phone: 281.528.1535

    email: rickr@rutledgelaw.net

    © 2024 All Rights Reserved

    We Serve Our Clients

    We have a track record of obtaining successful results throughout Texas -- in state and federal courts, as well as arbitrations. Led by an AV-Rated trial lawyer (Preeminent 2012, 2021, 2022, and 2023) who has been voted one of Houston's Best Lawyers in 2008 and again by his peers in 2017, our trial practice focuses on construction, commercial, tort, and indemnity/insurance. We also provide proactive counsel to small businesses on myriad topics. Unless otherwise noted, attorneys not certified by the Texas Board of Legal Specialization.

    email usour twitter linkdin
    powered by:
       Company Studio